• Costco vs. BJs vs. Sams Club: Which warehouse club is best?

    By: Mike Timmermann

    Updated:

    People sometimes give money expert Clark Howard a hard time when he talks about how much he loves Costco, but he’s not the only one!

    According to the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), Costco leads the pack of retailers in the category of department and discount stores. The warehouse club got a score of 83 on a 100-point scale.

    Meanwhile, competitors BJ’s Wholesale Club and Sam’s Club both earned an ACSI score of 80.

    RELATED: Clark Howard’s top 5 retailers to watch in 2018

    New report ranks America’s best department and discount stores

    Taking a look at the big picture, the study found that customer satisfaction with department and discount stores is down 1.3% to 77. That’s likely due to the competition from online retailers like Amazon.

    “It’s very challenging for brick-and-mortar retailers to weather the online onslaught without also providing a superior in-store customer experience,” the report said.

    When it comes to other discount retailers on the list, Dollar Tree (77) had a higher score than Dollar General (73), while Target (77) beat out Walmart (71) by six points. All four stores were down compared to the previous year.

    For department stores, Nordstrom was at the top of the list with an 81, while Sears scored the lowest with an ACSI score of 73.

    Take a look below at ACSI’s department and discount store rankings, from best to worst:

    Costco 83
    All others (average of smaller stores) 81
    Nordstrom 81
    BJ’s Wholesale Club 80
    Fred Meyer (Kroger) 80
    Sam’s Club (Walmart) 80
    Dillard’s 79
    J.C. Penney 79
    Kohl’s 79
    Meijer 79
    Belk 77
    Dollar Tree 77
    Macy’s 77
    Target 77
    Ross 76
    Big Lots 74
    Dollar General 73
    Sears 73
    Walmart 71

    Source: ACSI

    The annual ACSI Retail Report was based on 50,186 customer surveys collected throughout 2017. You can download a copy of the full report on the group’s website if you’re interested.

    Clark tip: How to save money at Costco, BJ’s and Sam’s Club 

    “Shop at stores with concrete floors” is Clark’s personal shopping motto. To avoid overspending, he has a rule that he doesn’t use a cart and only buys what he can carry in his hands — a tip many of his fans tell us they’ve started to follow.

    Which warehouse club is best? Check out our Twitter poll and let us know what you think in the comments section below!

    More Clark.com ways to save at retailers:

    Next Up:


  • Headline Goes Here

    Costco vs. BJs vs. Sams Club: Which warehouse club is best?

  • Headline Goes Here

    10 cities with the highest student loan balances

  • Headline Goes Here

    Insurance switcheroo: Some insurers rely on others to underwrite their policies

  • Headline Goes Here

    Traditional vs online banks: This chart shows how $5,000 can grow over 10 years

  • Headline Goes Here

    Credit Freeze Guide: The best way to protect yourself against identity theft