SC couple fights for custody of adopted child now in OK


Story Comments Share

Reported by: Adam Paluka
Updated: 1/05 10:23 am Published: 1/04 9:32 pm


A South Carolina couple is fighting to get their adopted daughter back in their custody after she was placed with her birth father, an Oklahoman, over the weekend.
 
Matt and Melanie Capobianco said goodbye to their two and half year-old daughter Veronica on Saturday.  “We're kind of reeling from it, and reliving having to hand her over in our minds constantly is painful,” the couple said.
 
While pregnant, Veronica's birth mother selected the couple and signed off on the adoption.
 
“We were there for the delivery, in the delivery room and Matt cut the umbilical cord, and she's been with us ever since except for the last four days,” Melanie told FOX23 Wednesday.
 
Veronica was removed from the Capobianco's home after her birth father, who is Cherokee, contested the adoption. The custody battle has been on-going since early 2010. The couple says when they first learned they would adopt Veronica; no mention was made of her Indian heritage.
 
“We were told that she was not an Indian child and so we didn't think it was going to make a difference,” Melanie said.
 
That was not the case. The Indian Child Welfare Act, passed in 1978, is a federal law that helps ensure Indian children stay with their birth parents or in other Indian homes whenever possible. That is the basis of the custody petition filed on behalf of Veronica’s birth father, who is represented by the Cherokee Nation.
 
“This isn't in her best interest. We're her family. This is her home,” Matt told FOX23.
 
“We understand the purpose of the Indian Child Welfare Act, but we feel that the ICWA is being abused, you know, we don't think this is what it was meant for,” the couple said.
 
Tulsa attorney June Stanley, who has handled many Indian adoptions, but is not involved in this case, says tribes will fight very hard to keep children from being placed in non-tribal homes.
 
“When a nation gives up its rights to its children its risking losing its culture, its ability to pass on language,” Stanley said.
 
She says if attorneys and perspective parents don't investigate if a child has tribal blood or linage, they could wind up in a similar situation.
 
“Is it common for people who don't practice in Indian law to unintentionally end up in a mess because they didn't know the law was out there? Absolutely.”
 
Now the Capobianco’s are using social media and the internet, http://www.saveveronica.com/, to try and get Veronica back.
 
“It's not about us. It's not about them. It's about our daughter and the best thing for her.”

Chrissi Ross Nimmo, the Assistant Attorney General who represented the Cherokee Nation in this case, gave FOX23 this statement:

“As a matter of law and policy, the Cherokee Nation’s attorney general’s office generally does not comment on juvenile cases due to their sensitive nature and confidential information. In an effort to quell the undue outside attention to this sensitive affair, the Cherokee Nation attorney general’s office filed a motion for a gag order in this case Wednesday afternoon, along with a motion to release the judge’s final order to the public. I ask that all parties involved in the matter respect the confidential nature of these juvenile court proceedings. The Cherokee Nation has 115 Indian Child Welfare employees and nine assistant attorneys general who work tirelessly to fight for the rights of Cherokee children and their parents, not only within our 14-county jurisdiction, but in tribal, state and federal courts across the nation.  The Indian Child Welfare Act was written to help keep Native American children with their families whenever possible – a concept embraced wholeheartedly by the Cherokee Nation.”


Story Comments Share

15 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of KOKI FOX23 - Tulsa

homenow - 3/30/2012 1:46 PM
0 Votes
dhowartist-you are right in the fact that there are children in foster care. Maybe your friends will raise one of them. Veronica has a real family and it isn't the C's.

jlu1980 - 1/8/2012 2:32 PM
0 Votes
I think that if the father and the tribe want this baby, maybe they should share her with the couple who have raised her since she was born, not just snatch her away to a person she does not know. Have the couple who adopted her bring her to the father and with them there to start with let her get to know him. he is a stranger to her. she is bound to be scared and not know what is going on, anyone remember the movie Losing Isaiah, if not maybe u should watch it and learn a thing or 2 about just taking a adopted kid away and giving them to a parent they do not know.

Jmtorres387 - 1/7/2012 6:19 PM
0 Votes
hes been fighting for his daughter since 2010 ever since she was born!!! Its not his fault it took this long for him to have his child back. I dont feel bad for the adopted parents when they knew her biological father was fighting for her.

Flicka - 1/7/2012 4:34 PM
0 Votes
I agree, if this father loves and wants the best for his daughter - GIVE HER BACK! I am 74 years old now but when I was 17 months old I was taken from the couple who had raised me from birth and given to another couple. I know this 2nd couple "walked the floor with me for a week, I would not stop crying." It took me until about 20 years ago for me to completely understand what affect this had on me but there is no doubt in my mind that this event, though I cannot remember it, permanently emotionally damaged me resulting in lack of trust in all my relationships - friends and marriages and work.

babyboomer46 - 1/7/2012 4:30 PM
0 Votes
I have worked in the adoption field for 16 years and know this for sure: Legally, when one of the birthparents is registered with a Native American tribe, both birthparents AND THE TRIBE must consent to the adoption. In this case, the adoptive parents got BAD legal advice from their lawyer or agency who apparently did not know the Indian Child Welfare Act well enough. Even if both birthparents sign consents, waivers or relinquishments, (whatever the legal document they use to give up parental rights), the tribe still has to give its consent or the adoption CANNOT go through. I feel sad for the little girl AND for the adoptive parents, who should sue whoever advised them legally in this matter. In my experience, the Cherokee Nation, in particular, is very strong and would never consent to an adoption if one of their registered members is involved. They reserve the right to find someone in the tribe to adopt and raise the child, even if BOTH birthparents wish to give up their parental rights.

kool mom - 1/6/2012 2:47 PM
0 Votes
To the father that little girl looked happy loved.She was with a real mommy and daddy.If you really have love for her let her go home.Look at her life she had with them.She has more than most childern will ever have.Please give her a chance to be happy and loved taken care of.You love her thats no question.But put yourself in her little shoes. How would you like be taken away from parents that love you.She is going to be so sad inside lost hurt maybe evan growing up to have emotional problems. Please let her be happy let her go home.Show her how much you really love her. That all that matters is her happiness.So when she grows up she'll find you and no how much you cared and loved her.

pcorry10 - 1/6/2012 12:04 PM
1 Vote
Sperm donor Brown doesn't even have enough sense to use a condom. He leaves a trail of illegitimate children. This about Veronica's rights to a stable loving environment which the adoptive family provided. The ONLY motive here is to increase his monthly free ride and get back at the birth Mother because she wouldn't marry him. Any parent truly interested in parenting would have supported their child regardless. This man is nothing but a pathetic opportunist who found a loop hole which our system is full of.His interest in "fathering" Veronica is equal to his interest in being a Cherokee.....NONE. SHAME ON YOU CHEROKEE NATION. I would really love to know exactly how much $$$ you get to destroy a child's life.

inthezone - 1/5/2012 7:41 PM
0 Votes
It seems that the Cherokee trump what their own members want or do. I don't think that losing one member is gonna be a big hit against millions. They are like the polygomist in Utah that forbid members to leave .... A cult- that's what they have become.

darlin616 - 1/5/2012 2:56 PM
0 Votes
I can not wait to hear the biological fathers side of the story. All we have heard is the adopitive parents side. And their version of what the biological mother has said. We havent actually heard either side from a biological parent.I feel for all parties involved as this is heart breaking for all and a no win situation for, one family is going to end up losing a child. I also think this belongs in the courts not in public news which will now make it harder on the child when she is taken out anywhere in public. I pray her biological father and family is not confronted by some angry outraged person while in public with this sweet little child.

dhowartist - 1/5/2012 12:04 PM
3 Votes
As a close female relative of the adoptive family, I have seen the love they have for Veronica, the tenderness they show her-she IS THEIR child! Sperm does not make a father as this is the reason so many children in our country are in foster homes and on welfare...And I totally believe that the "birth father" is looking for media attention and financial support from the Cherokee Nation who somehow cannot see how he is abusing everything they want to protect: human integraty, honesty, and a real connection with ancestry-Dustin Brown is making a mockery of his 1% heritage and should be ashamed. A child is dragged away from a secure and caring home with a mother and father to be raised by a male stranger who lives with his eldery parents????What kind of home is that?
FOX23 Weather Center
86°
Feels Like: 86°
High: 99° | Low: 69°
Clear
Top Stories
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.