Free Cell phones too good to be true?

Story Comments Share

Updated: 5/22/2012 4:41 pm Published: 5/22/2012 2:28 pm

Free cell phones! You may have seen the ads on TV or around town.

But is anything really free? And who's paying for the phones?

Pre-paid wireless phone companies are offering the deal -whether it's out of stores in strip malls and even out of the back of a van in a parking lot.

Nathan Samples went to YourTel America in a strip mall near 31st and Garnett in Tulsa.

Within five minutes, he had a phone - 2500 minutes of talk or text for the next month.

"I got a cell phone, just like that," he said.

All Nathan had to do was fill out some paperwork and show his ID and food stamp card.

"It was that easy," Nathan said.

There are 12 ways people can qualify for a free cell phone. If you get government assistance of any kind, you qualify. For example, if you live in public housing, get SSI, food stamps or your kids get a free or reduced lunch at school.

To put that in perspective, in the Tulsa Public School district, 80 percent of families qualify for a free or reduced lunch.

The employees signing up users at the YourTel America store told FOX23 almost everyone who comes in qualifies.

Even though it's advertised as free, the phone technically isn't free. But after taxes and fees, it's still cheap.

Nathan will pay about $9 a month for his plan. He was paying $65 a month for a cell phone before.

"You can't beat that," Nathan said.

So where does the money come from to pay for the free cell phones? If you're paying your cell phone bill, you're paying for them.

A portion of the fees taxes and fees you pay on your bill pays for the program - called Lifeline.

Local Tea Party Organizer Cris Kurtz with The USA Patriots gets riled up over taxes, including the extra fees and taxes she pays on her cell phone. Those fees and taxes add up to 17 percent of her bill, about $10 of her $61 bill.

"That's really outrageous. We complain about the nine percent sales tax," Cris said.

The FCC started Lifeline 25 years ago with landline phones.

But it's really taken off in the last four years when the feds allowed pre-paid wireless companies to get involved.

The number of subscribers jumped 57 percent to 12.5 million free phone lines last year.

That comes out to 1.75 billion dollars paid out last year.

But Oklahoma has seen one of the biggest jumps to 278,000 users last year - a 66 percent increase.

"It is a lot," Cris said. 

And here's why. Eighty-one companies have flooded Oklahoma with offers.

Because unlike neighboring states, where the FCC pays out an average of $8.24 per free phone plan, in Oklahoma, the average is more than $26 per person - more than any other state.

"Something is fishy about all of this," Cris said.

The difference is thanks to an additional $1.17 per month from the state for each subscriber. And in the 70 counties where there is tribal land, cell phone companies get an extra $25 dollars from the feds.

Making our state a gold mine for cell phones.

"It must be lucrative. Nobody does anything in America unless there's money," Cris said.

Cris questions the whole idea of giving away cell phones. She says food and clothing are necessities, not cell phones.

"I think of it as a luxury item," she said.

But Nathan says whether you're trying to get a job, track down your child or you need to call 911, everyone needs a cell phone.

"You can't find payphones anymore. You always need a cell phone when you're out and about," Nathan said.

He says the free cell phone will help him and his family avoid living paycheck to paycheck.

"Definitely support my family better, pay for necessities around the house, diapers," Nathan said.

"It's neat that we have assistance like this from the government," Nathan said. "This is huge opportunity."

The FCC admits the program has already had its share of corruption. Its investigation showed seven percent of customers were getting more than one free phone. That's a $33 million mistake.

The FCC says it's working to fix the problem, including creating a database so cell phone providers can check to make sure users don't already take part in the program.

Congressman John Sullivan sits on the committe with jurisdiction over the FCC.

"Our nation is $16 trillion in debt, and every single federal program needs to be under scrutiny for the waste, fraud and abuse of taxpayer dollars - the lifeline program is no exception... I assure you this is something we are looking into and taking seriuosly," Sullivan said in written statement.

Cell phone company representatives wouldn't tell FOX23 what providing the cell phones and plans cost them. But some of them will charge you per minute when you've used up your free monthly plan. So ask questions before you sign up.

And the FCC isn't finished. Its considering providing free high-speed internet to customers who qualify. That could be a couple years away.

Story Comments Share

5 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of KOKI FOX23 - Tulsa

1samna - 9/29/2012 11:28 PM
0 Votes
I have one of those "free" cell phones, & yes, a cell phone is a necessity! Without a cell phone no company will accept a job application from me or my mate! We don't have an alternative phone, without the "free" cell we would have NO phone. I was told when I applied for it, like everyone else at the food bank, that If you receive Social Security or welfare checks for as long as you receive that check the phone is absolutely free! I would *never* have signed up for this used cell phone otherwise! I received a postcard, with a PO Box for a return address and a bill amount that has to be paid by credit card to a 611 number or we lose this "free" cell phone! If I could afford a credit card why would I need a cheap or free phone? I don't remember signing a contract, just a just I received this phone and understand that if my finances change I will notify the company and lose the free phone thing. I never received a copy of that paperwork either, but had already signed, so am probably legally stuck with the bill.

Scuba024 - 9/21/2012 8:59 AM
0 Votes
I use to work for Easy Wireless which is out of Florida. This company comes to your state and makes up fraud accounts. They use address which are houses that are in rich neighborhoods or houses that have been on the sales market. Agents use white pages also to get addresses. Agents change addresses , names, socials, and birth dates. This company needs to be stopped. The company's name is TELECOM SERVICE BUREAU INC. the are out of Ocala Fl.

bowlerdave - 5/23/2012 11:40 AM
0 Votes
One interesting thing about this is, my brother and I went up to one of the vans to check it out. According to the app we were given, we were applying for a free line due to our enrollment in tribal roles, which neither of us are. Plus, that free phone with no contract, the app stated we were signing up for a 12 month contract paying almost $20 a month for that $1 a month phone line. Didn't get it.

t town253 - 5/22/2012 3:08 PM
0 Votes
Get a landline phone and you will be fine. Cox offers landlines for cheap. Give me a break. You can call 911, receive calls for jobs, and track down your children that way. People are too blasted spoiled.

t town253 - 5/22/2012 3:02 PM
1 Vote
This makes me mad. Since when is it a NECESSITY to have a cell phone?? I work too dang hard to pay for my own dog gone minutes and texts and data use to pay for someone elses too!! Next thing they are going to be giving away free i-pads and crap...which I dont even have!! This country has become such an enabling country.....I can understand people need food and electricity....but extra technology and electronic devices are not essential items to stay alive. Ugh this pisses me off!!!!!
FOX23 Weather Center
Feels Like: 46°
High: 67° | Low: 41°
Top Stories
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.