'American Idol' contestant admits he lied about military experience

Story Comments Share

Updated: 2/04/2013 9:46 am Published: 2/01/2013 11:15 pm

An American Idol hopeful from Tulsa won a golden ticket to Hollywood after allegedly lying to the show about his military service.

26-year-old Matt Farmer told American Idol producers his life story prior to the audition in Long Beach, CA.

“I was on a mission in Iraq. An IED exploded… and I woke up in the hospital.”

Farmer said he suffered from a traumatic brain injury and was receiving treatment. He also said the medication he was on would make him sterile but some how he got his wife pregnant and they now have a three-year-old girl.

Farmer’s battle buddies watched his audition on Wednesday night and were outraged. They wrote into a website called “Guardian of Valor.”

The site also has a Facebook page where called "Stolen Valor." The site is designed to “out” people who lie about their military service.

According to the site’s co-owner, an active duty military member who prefers to remain anonymous, it gets hundreds of messages a day. The site owner kindly allowed this information to be shared.

Some soldiers wrote:

Matt Farmer is a fraud. He is currently auditioning with American idol under false pretenses. I served with this person from Dec 2005 until he prematurely left for using banned substances, specifically medication not prescribed and alcohol.

The theatre was Ar Ramadi Iraq 1Bn 26inf blue spaders 1ID attached to 1-77ar 1ID and 2nd marine expeditionary force. His actions endangered the rest of his platoon and company and forced the rest of the company to be searched in what is called a “health and welfare” for illegal substances.

Sgt David Johnson

And the statements just kept pouring in:

His story on American idol is all lies. He did deploy with us, but never saw combat, never got blown up, never got a TBI and he was kicked out of Iraq because he drank alcohol while he was taking Accutane. I have pics, soldiers numbers, and his army records and timeline of his age and time in service will tell you it all doesn’t line up at all.

Hello, my name is John F. McManus and I would like to make a statement about something that has been brought to my attention. However, to begin with I’d like to state who I am and what my record very clearly shows. I was active duty Army Infantry from September 14, 2005 to February 6, 2010. Upon completion of Infantry basic training and AIT at Fort. Benning, Georgia, I was assigned to Bravo Company, 1st Battalion 26th Infantry Regiment, 1st Infantry Division in Schweinfurt, Germany and arrived early January 2006.

I deployed to Ramadi, Iraq late due to knee surgery and I was boots on ground on 4 January, 2007, and was a part of the troop surge, unit extensions and Operation Murfeesboro.

That being said, I saw Matt Farmer on American Idol telling stories of being blown up by and IED, getting medevaced out of theater and being discharged due to TBI, or, Traumatic Brain Injury. This is a bold faced lie to put it nicely. Matt Farmer was medevaced from Camp Ramadi, that is true, but the reason he was airlifted out is because of a far different reason. Matt Farmer had an acne problem as young men sometimes do, and his mother was mailing him prescription strength acne medication.

What happened on the night of September 4th, 2007 is the following: Matt Farmer got his hands on some whiskey that another soldier received in the mail.

He proceeded to get drunk throughout the evening and at some point in the night he had a seizure resulting from a reaction between his acne medication and alcohol. He drunkenly gave names of every soldier involved in the incident and even some that weren’t. He was taken from Camp Ramadi that night and wound up back in Germany. He then proceeded to make claims of both PTSD and TBI so that he wouldn’t have to redeploy back to Iraq to face both the consequences of him drinking in theater and also the soldiers that felt betrayed by him.

He spend the remainder of his days in the WTU (Warrior Transition Unit) and was eventually medically discharged for the ailments he claimed, effectively ending his military service somewhere between November ’07 and January ’08. I cannot give you a better time frame for his discharge as I was home on 45 day block leave beginning December 7th, 2007.

Matt Farmer is no war hero. Matt Farmer is a pathological liar that has used the blood, sweat and tears of real, hardworking, tough, brave and honorable Infantry soldiers to paint himself as someone he most certainly is not. He doesn’t deserve to be placed in the same category as the centuries of American Infantrymen who fought for and in some cases died for this great land. The truth will come out and Matt Farmer will regret the day he lied to America.

John F. McManus


Team Leader
United States Army

FOX23 News talked with Specialist John McManus over the phone on Friday evening.

“I was shocked and angry after I watched Farmer’s audition,” said McManus. “He was not the type of soldier you could trust. Our paths first crossed at Basic together. He has no honor. He lied. He is an adult and he made a conscious decision to lie on national television. He told a sob story when he confessed to the lies. He never would have confessed if all of us did not produce these comments. He sounds like he is telling a sob story when he confessed.”

After Friday’s story on The Guardian of Valor was picked up by national and local Green County news in Oklahoma Farmer confessed it all. He responded initially by blaming American Idol for editing his interview incorrectly. 

He wrote:

I wanted to contact you directly and let you know that American Idol took certain things I said out of context.  Three pictures that were shown were not ones provided by myself but stock photos THEY used.

I at NO time gained any monetary values about my story that was used on American Idol and want it to also be known that i am no longer apart of the show (which technically i am not suppose to divulge) BUT as I know that there are people upset I also want to let you know that certain things that were said are true.

I did drink and overdose on pills. Was Medevaced to Al Asad where I was there for several days (Not sure how many as most of it was in a drug induced blur) than sent to Laundstill Germany. There they did lots of psyhc evals where they told me i had PTSD and anxiety disorder. I was then transferred Back to my unit in Schweinfurt Germany. I was never KICKED out of iraq. I was told that I needed to go back to my unit to undergo further evaluations…”

Then a few hours later he wrote:

UPDATE 20130201 Matt sent us the following statement, in this statement he admits to the lies he told.
Everything you have read is correct. It was ALL lies. I in fact HAVE lied since a younger age and had a problem with it. I am coming out and making a statement (even though I was instructed not to) because I DO want to come clean. Just so everyone knows I’m not reviving any sort of disability for TBI. Let it also be known that I left country 2.5 months before the rest of the unit came home, I stayed in the army PST my ETS date and was released from full service (whether active or reserve) in 2009.

I do in fact take FULL responsibility for the actions and words I have said, and know that this will never go away. In NO way was I looking to take from everyone who has served. I started to believe my own lies. And after I believed them… I would catch myself talking like it had happened to me my entire life. To the gentleman above who talked about going to the VA I am doing just that, the “cocktail” u refer to Has been my deterrent for the last couple of years as I feel like when I was medicated while at FT sill and even at Schwinefurt It was never “correct”. Never the less.

The lies end here. I want to base the life I have left on nothing but what is real and genuine and in the here and now. I am EXTREaMLY remorseful and VERY upset that I allowed myself to take from the hard work of the guys that I was deployed with among others. To think that I would go on a national tv show and get away with continuing a lie so big, and so deeply imbedded in my life and brain… Is ridiculous. Hindsight is always 20/20. The work the blue spader a did overseas was impeccable and I regret that I took from that. To EVERYONE but more importantly the men I served with, I AM DEEPLY REGRETFUL AND SORRY. my road to figuring out how to make a life built on trust starts now. It starts with getting help. And starts with this message.

I was told to keep quiet and not talk to anyone, and I have decided that what’s best for me and my family is to come out and end the insanity. I indeed have many many things to work with and need to get a lot of help doing it. Again I apologize to everyone that I have come across and hurt or lied too.

I at no time was a sniper, was never deployed to Afghanistan, did a single tour in Iraq, and was never at any time hit or wounded by an IED

Matt Farmer

During the producing of this story FOX23 News got a tip that Matt Farmer had a $3,000 warrant out for his arrest. He has been busted several times in Tulsa for writing hot checks for up to $20,000. His warrant is for failing to appear in court and was issued in January 2012. 

FOX23 News confirmed this with the Oklahoma State Courts Network and the Tulsa Police Department. In 2010, in Oklahoma County, Farmer deferred his sentence for obtaining money or property under false pretense. OSCN said he violated his sentence so now an application to revoke is pending in that charge.

Story Comments Share

10 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of KOKI FOX23 - Tulsa

TulsaTime77 - 2/4/2013 9:38 PM
0 Votes
In my opinion I think its pathetic that Fox23 ran this story. Check it. The guy lied about that specific experience in the war. He obviously did it to appeal to the emotions of the judges to get his ticket to Hollywood. He lied. So what? How many times a week does Hollywood and showbusiness lie and fabricate stories to get ratings? Lol Fox news is the worse about lying to the public and over hyping the news to scare the public, for what? And agenda, and ratings! So Fox23 has to run this story and trash this guy for what? Why would the public really need to know this information? Who stood to gain by running this story? Fox23 for...ratings, and to be the news cast that "uncovered the truth first." So what? Haha its not like the guy didn't still fight for your freedom (if you wanna call it that) in the war. So yeah shame on Matt Farmer for lying, but shame on Fox23 for uncovering truth that didn't need to be uncovered. I'm sure every one of their staff has some dirt on them they don't want people knowing. For example the conduct I've heard about Chera Kimiko. Ha...Grow up Fox23!

AGdollfashions - 2/4/2013 3:46 PM
0 Votes
old news old news old news......

ADArmy - 2/3/2013 10:00 PM
2 Votes
Ha Ha I agree, FBWatchdog bro you are a real tool. I have never in my entire life seen someone rant so much about nothing on facebook. That is one of the worst pages I have ever witnessed on FB. Seem to me you have a personal vendetta against someone. And you are using your FB pages to try and get revenge, I think yo are going about it te wrong way bro. You are no going to damage that page, from what I have seen thy do good things. I am thinking you may be a poser they outted...youmadbro?

Stanwinston - 2/3/2013 9:21 PM
2 Votes
To the FBwatchdog dude, I went to those pages and you are a raving lunatic. Nothing you say on those pages makes a bit of sense. Looks to me like you are mad because they did not take your case. Where does it say they HAVE to take a case because you want them to? So what they sell shirts, so does 500 other facebook pages. Nothing illegal about that, and you seem to love to talk to yourself on those pages. I mean it is obvious all those pages are you, I can tell by your typing style. So stop trying to cause trouble and bring false accusations against a site that is doing great things. Just because they would not do something you wanted then to. Last time I checked it is a free country, and I don't think they have to bow down to you. I have seen you posting everywhere trying to get attention to your pages, you know thats considered spamming.

FBWatchdog - 2/3/2013 7:50 PM
0 Votes
If you visit on Facebook the page http://www.facebook.com/CoalitionofMilitaryPages they have given the folks from Stolen Valor (http://www.facebook.com/StolenValor) opportunity to respond to the allegation that they allowed a proven poser to use their page to fake his service and impersonate another soldier as they did nothing about it. The Stolen Valor page responded by using information collected from the Marine from RMRSF to verify HIS service with them to spread it all over Facebook as well as email him threats like "we know where you live" in a failed attempt to intimidate him from continued outing of the Stolen Valor page. They lie about how many people are involved ith their page. They lie about their connections to the actual Stolen Valor website which is non-existent. More than half of the "investigations" they claim as "outings" on their page were conducted by others, not their page. All they do is post what others bring to them, but for some reason they protected a known poser (Shawn Hoffman) on their page. In a failed attempt supposedly to clear this up, all they did was continue to attack the Marine who brought this to their attention (as you can see on a screen shot by them on this page) and then put out his personal information in an attempt to intimidate him from pursuing this information about their page. They do make money of selling T-shirts and others page-related property to their fans. They have been invited to respond to questions on the Coalition page and have failed to respond directly to any of them.

FBWatchdog - 2/3/2013 7:40 PM
0 Votes
There is a story within the story. The "guardianofvalor" page that Fox News used to share this story in itself has fraudulent practices. They use the name "Stolenvalor" on Facebook and continuously have proof brought to them by other Facebook members including a recent one where an army guy posted a link ON THEIR PAGE claiming to be another army guy who was a decorated soldier and they declined to even look at the link and defended a poser right on their Facebook page. If you go to Facebook and find "Coalition of Military Pages", they confronted "Stolen Valor" with the evidence and all they got was harassed and threats. In fact, the individual from the page "Real Marines Respect Semper Fi" originally brought the information to their attention and they got harassed and attacked on the Stolen Valor page who did nothing. Their main goal is to use other people's investigative work as they sell T-shirts.

cattleokie - 2/3/2013 10:50 AM
0 Votes
He LIED, he LIED, he LIED. That is the bottom line !!!!!!! It seems like these days that people Do Not give a rats a#s about lying to get an upper edge! And also the other bad thing about it he used his kid in the whole ordeal to try & get the upper edge on the competition. Even the president used lies & kids to try & get his gun ban started even through he is a active gun shooter! WHEN WILL IT END ! PROBABLY NEVER! I am GLAD for that Matt do he is no longer on the show!

Mayor Maynot - 2/3/2013 1:37 AM
1 Vote
Plumb sad. Sad that this guy had to make it up like that to feel accepted. Sad that people he knew would take away a chance at a new life (they knew he might not be a good soldier) but he might have been a good pretender. Everybody's favorite soldier is John Wayne. Heck he was never really a soldier. His name wasn't even John Wayne. But he was a good enough pretender that google capitalizes his name. Not too bad for an imaginary person. Besides all that American idol is just for entertainment purposes anyway. Lighten up. It's not like he stole the national trust. BTW Google didn't capitalize American idol.

GodsGutterPunk - 2/2/2013 11:08 AM
0 Votes

dukshanee - 2/2/2013 8:32 AM
0 Votes
thanks farmer for representing Tulsa you a@@hole you!!!!
FOX23 Weather Center
Feels Like: 32°
High: 74° | Low: 37°
Partly Cloudy
Top Stories
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.